Nannycare vs Kabrita Goat Milk Formula: Which Should Parents Choose? (2026)

Nannycare and Kabrita are two of the most trusted names in goat milk formula, and many US parents comparing European options end up choosing between exactly these two. Both are goat milk–based, both use lactose as the main carbohydrate, and both are made to strict European standards — yet they take noticeably different approaches to protein, fat, and added ingredients. Nannycare follows a minimal-ingredient, whole goat milk philosophy, while Kabrita builds a whey-adjusted recipe with added prebiotics and a patented fat blend. This guide compares them side by side so you can decide which approach fits your baby and your family.

Nannycare and Kabrita at a Glance

Before diving into ingredients, it helps to understand where each formula comes from and the philosophy behind it. If you are still weighing goat milk against cow milk options in general, our guide on goat milk vs cow milk formula is a good place to start.

About Nannycare

Nannycare is a UK brand with deep roots in goat milk nutrition — it was one of the pioneers of goat milk infant formula and contributed to the research that led the EU to approve goat milk protein for infant formula in 2014. The goat milk itself comes from pasture-raised goats in New Zealand, and the finished formula is sold primarily in the UK market. Nannycare's defining feature is simplicity: it is built on full cream (whole) goat milk, keeps the natural protein profile of goat milk, uses lactose as the carbohydrate, and adds relatively few extra ingredients beyond the vitamins and minerals required by regulation. EuromallUSA carries the UK 900g cans in Stages 1, 2, and 3. For a deeper look at the brand, see our Nannycare goat milk formula review.

About Kabrita

Kabrita is a Dutch brand made in the Netherlands with goat milk collected from a cooperative of Dutch family farms. Where Nannycare keeps things minimal, Kabrita takes a more engineered approach: it starts from skimmed goat milk, adds goat whey protein to shift the whey-to-casein ratio closer to that of breast milk, includes added GOS prebiotic fibers, and uses a vegetable oil blend featuring a high proportion of sn-2 palmitic acid (a fat structure similar to the position of palmitic acid in breast milk fat). EuromallUSA carries the Dutch 800g cans in Stages 1, 2, and 3, plus smaller 400g cans. You can read a full breakdown in our Kabrita goat milk formula review.

↑ Back to Table of Contents

Side-by-Side Comparison Table

↑ Back to Table of Contents

Protein and Fat: The Biggest Difference

The clearest philosophical split between these two formulas is how they handle goat milk itself.

Nannycare keeps the milk whole. By starting with full cream goat milk, Nannycare retains the natural goat milk fat alongside its natural protein balance, which is casein-dominant — the way goat milk naturally is. The brand's position is that gentle processing and fewer added ingredients let the inherent qualities of goat milk do the work. Parents drawn to short, recognizable ingredient lists often gravitate to this approach.

Kabrita re-engineers the ratio. Kabrita starts with skimmed goat milk and adds back goat whey protein, shifting the whey-to-casein ratio closer to that of mature breast milk. It then rebuilds the fat profile with a vegetable oil blend that includes a high proportion of sn-2 palmitic acid, mimicking how fat is structured in breast milk. Families who want a goat formula modeled more closely on breast milk composition often find Kabrita's approach appealing.

Neither approach is universally "better" — they reflect different design philosophies, and babies can do well on either. Both meet the same EU compositional requirements for infant formula. If your baby is currently on a different formula and you're considering a change, our guide on transitioning to a new infant formula explains how to make the switch gradually.

↑ Back to Table of Contents

Prebiotics, DHA, and Added Ingredients

Prebiotics. Kabrita includes added GOS (galacto-oligosaccharides), one of the most studied prebiotic fibers in infant nutrition, intended to support the growth of beneficial gut bacteria. Nannycare historically avoided added prebiotics as part of its minimal-ingredient philosophy, though newer UK recipes have introduced 2'-FL (a human milk oligosaccharide) — check the current can to see which recipe you're receiving.

DHA and ARA. All infant formulas sold under EU/UK rules must contain DHA. Nannycare uses a plant-based DHA from algal oil. Kabrita includes both DHA and ARA; the DHA source has varied by version and market, so verify the label if the source matters to you (for example, if you prefer fish-free ingredients).

What neither contains. Both formulas use lactose as the carbohydrate — no corn syrup, glucose syrup, or maltodextrin in these recipes — and neither contains soy protein or added sucrose. Neither brand is certified organic; if organic certification is your priority, European organic goat options like Holle Goat or Jovie may be a better fit, which we compare in our complete goat milk formula guide.

↑ Back to Table of Contents

Stages, Can Sizes, and Preparation

Both brands follow the standard European stage system. Nannycare Stage 1 is a first infant milk suitable from birth, Stage 2 is a follow-on milk from 6 months, and Stage 3 is a growing-up milk for toddlers from 1 to 3 years. Kabrita mirrors this: Stage 1 for 0–6 months, Stage 2 for 6–12 months, and Stage 3 toddler milk from 12 months. If you're unsure when to move between stages, our guide on when to switch baby formula stages walks through the timing.

Practical differences worth noting: Nannycare's 900g cans are among the largest in the European goat formula category, which can mean fewer cans per month. Kabrita's standard Dutch can is 800g, with 400g cans available — handy for travel or trying the formula before committing. Both prepare like any European powder formula; each brand's scoop size and water ratio differ, so always follow the instructions on your specific can. Our step-by-step European formula preparation guide covers safe mixing and storage basics.

↑ Back to Table of Contents

Which Formula May Suit Your Family?

Whichever direction you lean, the right choice depends on your baby's age, how they tolerate the formula, and your pediatrician's guidance — especially if your baby has a diagnosed cow milk protein allergy, since goat milk protein is not an appropriate substitute in that case.

↑ Back to Table of Contents

Frequently Asked Questions

Is goat milk formula safe for babies with cow milk allergy?

No. Goat milk proteins are similar to cow milk proteins, and most babies with a diagnosed cow milk protein allergy will also react to goat milk formula. Talk to your pediatrician about an appropriate hypoallergenic option instead.

Are Nannycare or Kabrita organic?

Neither is certified organic. Nannycare emphasizes pasture-raised New Zealand goats and minimal processing; Kabrita emphasizes non-GMO ingredients and Dutch family farms. For certified-organic goat formula, parents typically look at Holle Goat or Jovie.

Can I use Nannycare or Kabrita from birth?

Yes — both Nannycare Stage 1 and Kabrita Stage 1 are complete infant formulas suitable from birth under European regulations. Always use the stage that matches your baby's age.

Can I switch between Nannycare and Kabrita?

Many families transition between goat milk formulas gradually, mixing increasing proportions of the new formula over several days to a week. If your baby has special feeding needs, check with your pediatrician first.

Which formula tastes better?

Taste is subjective and babies' preferences vary, so there's no reliable answer — some babies happily accept either. The whole-milk base of Nannycare and the whey-adjusted recipe of Kabrita do produce slightly different flavor profiles, and a small 400g Kabrita can makes low-cost trial runs easier.

Do the ingredients ever change?

Yes. Both brands periodically update recipes (for example, DHA sources and added oligosaccharides). The current package label is always the authoritative source for the exact formulation you're buying.

↑ Back to Table of Contents

Recommended Products at EuromallUSA

Related Articles

Final Thoughts

Nannycare and Kabrita represent two thoughtful but different takes on goat milk formula. Nannycare bets on the goodness of whole goat milk with as little intervention as possible; Kabrita fine-tunes goat milk toward the composition of breast milk with added whey, prebiotics, and a structured fat blend. Both use lactose, both meet rigorous European standards, and both have loyal followings among US families. The best fit comes down to your ingredient philosophy, your baby's tolerance, and your pediatrician's advice.

↑ Back to Table of Contents